Flaherty's Future with Tigers: A Decision with Implications
The Tigers' decision to exercise Flaherty's player option for 2026 is a strategic move with significant implications for the team's future. Flaherty, a right-handed pitcher, signed a two-year contract with a player option for 2026 in February, making it a one-year deal with a potential extension. The option was initially valued at $10 million, but it doubled to $20 million once Flaherty met the escalator clause for 15 starts this season.
Despite a challenging season, Flaherty's performance warrants attention. His 8-15 record and 4.64 ERA reflect a regression from his 2024 numbers, but his 3.85 FIP suggests he pitched better than his base numbers indicate. Flaherty's top form was evident in his six scoreless innings and seven strikeouts against the Blue Jays and seven scoreless innings with nine strikeouts against the Astros. However, he also faced setbacks, including two outings with eight runs given up.
Flaherty's impact was evident in a September win over the Yankees, where he pitched five scoreless innings and seven strikeouts. His regular-season performances against Cleveland, including back-to-back losses, and his relief role in the AL Wild Card Series and AL Division Series showcased his versatility. The Tigers' decision to exercise the option avoids a potential rotation hole, especially with injuries to Reese Olson and Jackson Jobe.
The Tigers' options for the 2026 season include keeping Flaherty, Tarik Skubal, Casey Mize, and Troy Melton as their top returning starters. They could also consider Keider Montero's return to the rotation or exercise the option on José Urquidy. Additionally, adding a veteran starter is a possibility to strengthen the staff and prepare for potential free-agent departures of Skubal and Mize. Flaherty's decision to stay with the Tigers is a strategic move, ensuring stability and continuity for the team's future success.
